I just (about an hour ago) finished watching Superman Returns. Before I spill my thoughts on it, let it be known at some point you are going to see big, bold letters that say Spoiler Warning. Well, now you’ve already seen them of course, but that was just a test. The second time you see them, it will be for real.
Altogether, I’d say it was a pretty entertaining film. Not as solid as Batman Begins, I thought, and definitely not in the same league as Spider-man 1 and 2, but I think that has to do with the fact that it’s pretty hard to tell a good Superman story because the guy is so damn tough. Superman himself can never really be in any danger so you have to keep putting the people around him in peril and you can only do that so many times in a single movie before it gets old. Ultimately, the movie’s an homage to the old Christopher Reeve ones, which still makes it fun to watch. I hope if they do another though, that they’ll try for a different approach because we now have 5 Superman movies done in that style.
A few quick and dirty points:
1. Because Kate Bosworth and Brandon Routh both look so incredibly youthful and fit, I sometimes felt I was watching Superman: Laguna Beach.
2. Bosworth was not bad as Lois. She’s not as memorable as Margot Kidder - Kate doesn’t really display the personality for it - but her performance was decent. Routh on the other hand takes all of his acting cues from Christopher Reeve, hunching over and stuttering in a high pitched voice as Clark Kent, and walking around with his chin up and chest out as Superman. Reeve did it better though. Routh’s Superman is a little more cute than heroic.
3. Kevin Spacey probably has the best performance of the bunch (with Sam Huntington in second place as Jimmy Olsen). Admittedly, it’s a re-hash of Gene Hackman’s interpretation of Lex Luthor, but Spacey adds a darker edge to it and actually makes Luthor dangerous. You also get a few hints as to how Luthor sees himself as the champion of humanity in relation to Superman’s alien, god-like stature.
4. Cyclops couldn’t win a girl if his life depended on it. What is it with James Marsden playing the straight-shooter yet loserly second-fiddle love interest to all the pretty leading ladies?
5. The awe and respect that people (in the film) have for Superman sent chills down my spine. The first time he flies into action and saves the day, you can feel his presence and the impact that he has on the people of Metropolis. I think these moments are the best parts of the film.
6. Kumar beat up Superman.
7. While it worked in Spider-man, creating a digital replica of Routh in costume doesn’t really succeed, chiefly because Superman doesn’t wear a mask. It’s an impressive digital model and I can only wish I could make something like that, but still - I can tell the difference, especially when they cut back and forth between the model’s face and Routh’s. It would be interesting to know if other people can tell the difference though.
Spoiler Warning - read on if you don’t care.
Bryan Singer has a very interesting take on Superman. First of all, the Christian allusions/imagery are all over the place: the disembodied voice of Jor El telling us over and over again how Superman has been sent as our savior; the recurring theme of the father-son relationship; the poses that Superman tends to be in (how many times is he floating around with his arms oustretched, hands out?). Also, if you pay close attention to the beginning of the movie, the scene of Martha Kent holding a battered Superman in her arms after he crash lands in the field is incredibly reminiscent of the Pieta. Combined with Routh’s cutesy acting skills, you end up with a much more gentle version of Superman, softer and more vulnerable. I would even go so far to say that this Superman is just a bit more feminine than any other incarnation we’ve seen before. He is most definitely not heroic in the classically macho-hero sense.
Another interesting thing that Singer has done is he’s made Superman the father of an illegitimate child. He’s an absentee dad, and Lois is taking care of their son while engaged to another man who thinks that it’s his son. In any other movie, this is standard fare. But this…this is Superman, the original superhero. As the guy who started it all, he, of all others, would be the one most identified with classical wholesome family-values. But here in this movie, that’s just not the case anymore (you’ll note that when Perry White talks about what Superman stands for, he says “Truth and Justice,” not “Truth, Justice, and the American Way.” Interesting, eh?). Personally, I think it’s a dig at the whole notion of wholesome family-values. They’re unrealistic expecations that even Superman can’t live up to because families are complex and unpredictable. It doesn’t make him any less super though.
The film is filled with these little complexities, but they’re never played up and it’s just wasted potential in the end. It’s still entertaining though, and if you’re a fan of Superman and the old movies, you’re gonna get goosebumps during the opening credits.